The world is not the internet

Recently, in the ethics class I teach, we talked about attention. Simone Weil said:

“The authentic and pure values—truth, beauty and goodness—in the activity of a human being are the result of one and the same act, a certain application of the full attention to the object.”

What we give our attention to is really important. And yet, when I look at my life, my attention is often in the wrong place. I like having my phone in my hand. I like having noise around me. I sometimes get distracted with my own thoughts, and I don’t hear what someone is saying to me. My attention is often divided, unfocused.

The things on the internet often capture our attention until we don’t know quite how to attend to anything else.

I am frustrated often with the content I find. Mindless scrolling that no longer seems human anymore. News stories about all the terrible things that are happening. I want to be well-informed, I think, and here is the way to get of all this information, and yet it is full of slop and garbage and those seeking fame. I feel like the world is both crumbling around me, and that I am supposed to laugh at some funny meme at the same time.

I write on this blog and very few people see this. Sometimes I see other subscriber counts it’s easy to feel like what I’m doing doesn’t matter at all. The numbers say that others are reaching thousands and millions of people, and I don’t have that kind of reach. My contributions to the internet are so small and insignificant. No one is paying attention to me.

But the world is not the internet. The world is more than the internet. Those metrics fall apart when we remember what the world is like.

In my ethics class, I usually have an audience of about 25 people twice a week. I talk and share, but I also get to listen. I like the listening part of it, the connection between people. Everyone there is important. My students often surprise me: they are bringing such a depth of experience to the world, each of them with wildly different stories, and yet we can connect over shared values, shared frustrations, shared questions. We try to find answers, but the finding of connection is even better, the feeling of sorting through these problems and ideas together, not on our own.

I’m also writing this dissertation and, in my attempt to actually finish it, I have to close myself off and just write and edit and revise. I think I prefer the real-world conversations that don’t need answers, just ideas. But what I am trying to create is a conversation starter, not an authoritative statement. Not many will read my dissertation. But it still feels like it matters. Not only for the project itself, but for what I’ve learned from doing it and what I can share. Not with a huge audience, but with a few people who might find the ideas helpful, who might become part of that conversation.

I talked to one person at an academic conference in depth about some of my ideas. In the metrics of the internet, one connection and one view and one conversation doesn’t matter. But in the world, those singular conversations seem to matter the very most.

On the internet, social media makes us feel disgustingly distracted. News sites make the world seem like it’s falling apart. Search results are filled with AI slop. We encounter a great number of trolls stirring up contention and advertisers looking for our money.

But in the world, the world outside my screen, I encounter connection that feels beautiful and true and good. The world is a beautiful place. Not all of it. But enough that it makes it feel like there is hope, something to be optimistic about–and that there is so much good right now and always.

I see a rainbow hiking down from the peak of the mountain with my husband. I pick up handfuls of snow and see the small crystals while sledding with my daughter. I laugh with an audience as we sit and watch our community put on a musical. I am embraced in a hug that lets me breathe. I meet a new person who is different from me, and yet we find ways to connect. I carve out a space in the world that is home and refuge.

The internet is not the thing we should attend to, though it can give us glimpses and connection into those more important things. There is a real-life world that deserves our attention, the world that has existed before the screens and will keep on existing when we put the screens away. A world full of people, art, connection, ideas, hope. A world where there will always be beauty. Beauty that is not newsworthy and not viewed by thousands or millions. But beauty and connection and love that is more significant, that makes us realize we are not alone.

My life is full of moments that will be forgotten, unrecorded, and viewed only by one person–and those moments are what make life so full of joy.

The end of the internet search

Recently, I’ve searched things on the internet like usual. Questions I have about cooking or electronics or philosophy or whatever.

What to do when I burn my chili? AI results almost entirely, most from the same website with hundreds of posts that are only slightly different from each other. (The answer: it will always taste sort of burnt.)

Can I buy Costco pizza without a Costco card? Mostly AI results with varying answers and no actual research or information to back it up. (The answer: no.)

How to adjust self-closing door hinges? I find a post written by an obviously fake DIYer with an unpronounceable name, fake picture, is a certified expert in nothing, and wants to thank the Almighty for his furniture business, interior design business, carpentry skills, and search engine optimization specialty. (The answer: use a small nail or something, insert into a hole, rotate, take out the pin, put the pin again in a different spot to adjust tension.)

Some searches do come up with fairly good results, but the internet is now awash with fake people who have no experience because they aren’t actual people.

Even when I look for images and explicitly say to hide AI images, my search results are still full of AI that are often completely inaccurate depictions of whatever I want to see.

I don’t want AI results. I’m intentionally not using Google anymore because I don’t want Gemini to tell me an often-incorrect answer. I want to hear from people. I want advice from people.

And the people are now hidden. They aren’t gone, but I can’t find them anymore.

It’s really sad to realize that people put up all this useful information on the internet, often at great effort, and then AI used their words as training data and took over their jobs. I don’t want to live in that world, but here I am.

I’m realizing that I cannot use the internet like I used to. I can’t go to a search engine and type in what I’m looking for, because it will give me a bunch of robotic slop that only faintly pretends to be human.

I have to look at a website in a search result and see if it’s something I recognize, like a news source or a website I’ve been to in the past that I know comes from humans, and not robots. But I wish I could find those personal websites of people sharing good advice from their own experience. I miss having those available to me. All the recipe blogs were so good, and now so many of them are fake.

I’m not sure what to do now.

Maybe search Reddit? It’s full of bots too, though it can be useful.

Maybe just look at Wikipedia? I actually do look at Wikipedia a lot, and I’m grateful for their anti-AI policies. But it isn’t good for everything.

Do I use social media sites with their addictive algorithms? Maybe use WikiHow? Rely on the news tab of search results? Do I make a list of sites that claim not to use AI?

If you have any good advice for me, I would love it. How do you find the humans amid the outpouring of AI-generated content?

Here I am, writing on my own little website, feeling like the robots are taking over. I want human advice and human connection, but the internet is no longer the place for that. If I don’t see you face to face, how can I know you are real?

How do you know I am real, and that this isn’t just an AI-generated post?

Internet Nostalgia

I’ve been around long enough that I remember the early days of the internet and I’ve seen a lot of changes. I remember searching something (before Google, on Ask Jeeves or AltaVista) and finding lists of mainly pages of just random text-based websites that tech-savvy people had stuck up. I remember going to the computer lab with my friends before school and sharing funny things and videos–there was no YouTube, just random trains of emails and word-of-mouth of the best websites (like Homestar Runner). I remember a conversation with my uncle during the early days of Wikipedia, when a lot of people were skeptical that it would ever be any good. I had a Juno email address and a Hotmail address, and email was often used to share links with friends and family. I started a blog in somewhere around 2005 or so, and I’ve had my own website of some sort ever since. Back then, blogs were the main way to connect–I remember meeting people online in the comment section of my favorite author’s website. I was also active on a self-hosted forum (no Reddit) and found a sense of community in that small group talking about reading and writing. I would go to Amazon to buy books. And instant message people because texting was hard.

That is just a whole bunch of nostalgia, and I don’t want the internet to be what it was in the 1990s and 2000s. There are some things I like about the internet now, like how Wikipedia is really good.

I got on Instagram a few days ago, and I scrolled through stuff I didn’t care about. I haven’t checked social media very much lately. I used to do it all the time, sometimes for hours. But if I’m honest, I’ve never really enjoyed it. I get sick of seeing faces of people who are good at producing a lot of content, but they aren’t my friends or people I care about. Those shortform videos are so jarring–too short to really convey that much, and always viewed in large, random, confusing batches. I think we might keep scrolling over and over again because none of them leave us feeling satisfied. Our attention is actually starving to be engaged in something. It’s like eating too much popcorn or candy when we’re really hungry for dinner.

I posted some pictures on Instagram. That’s what Instagram used to be, just pictures. I like creating content, but I don’t like trying to game what’s going to be popular. I’m still blogging. I’m still posting pictures.

So much of the internet is about selling attention to corporations. Advertisements are everywhere. We all go to the same few websites. It’s mind-numbing, frustrating.

The good thing about having your own website is you are largely in control of it. You can take up space, have time to be yourself and present yourself in the way that you want to. You aren’t fitting yourself and optimizing yourself into a corporation’s view of what should bring the most views, chasing attention.

Sometimes I wish more people blogged again–people I know and care about. I have quite a few blogs I used to follow that have quit in favor of more lucrative social media posts. Blogging is rarely done by individuals anymore. People did it for a while and then they stopped, leaving a graveyard of former blogs that have since died.

I wish I could go on a website and not be inundated with ads and sponsored posts. I wish I didn’t search things and get false information from A.I. I want to visit website of people who are sharing what they love instead.

But I think we can bring back elements of the internet that we miss. Homestar Runner is still posting videos, after all, and you do not have to visit YouTube to view them. I’m still blogging and occasionally posting pictures. And I still very much enjoy and support long-form content and people who are doing really creative things on their own websites. I like when people post on occasion something meaningful.

We used to have blogrolls and share our favorite blogs with each other. So here are some fun things:

It’s Nicky Case!
Home – Utah’s Adventure Family
xkcd
Cool Things We Found
Neocities: Create your own free website!

Maybe I should share more often? But I like discovering things randomly, hearing about them from friends, connecting with people. And I don’t need that much of the internet in my life either. The most important part of my life is real-life interaction with actual people.

Happier Without Technology

The internet is a wonder. When I want a movie streamed on a computer, I have 24 frames per second being sent to me over thousands of miles almost instantaneously–and not over wires, but straight through the air in waves of information. I don’t understand how that works.

I can look up about any question whenever I want it answered–like what the standard frame rate is for movies. Which started a rabbit hole about why we have that particular frame rate, and I’ve learned a bit about the history of recording video, CGI and video games, high frame rate, and augmented reality.

I could go into a rabbit hole about the origin of the phrase rabbit hole, which I’m pretty sure is related to Alice in Wonderland, but I will resist. Her rabbit hole was a dream, actually–a fall straight into absurdity.

And that’s what the internet feels like. It feels absurd. It feels like disappearing cats that pop up in unexpected places. It feels like mixed up life that doesn’t sound quite right anymore.

I am pretty sure I would be happier without the internet. And without smart phones. And without computers, even.

The thing is, I don’t have to use them. I don’t have to turn on my computer or check my smart phone. I don’t have to have a Facebook account and I don’t have to follow people on Instagram. But I do.

What stops me from cutting the cord, from waking up from this dream of absurdity and actually living my life instead of falling into the rabbit hole?

Quite a few things: connecting with people, searching answers for simple questions, creating and sharing posts and videos, watching television shows, reading news, taking classes, shopping, listening to music, etc.

There are so many good things that technology can do.

I have invested in blocking software–blocking websites in the morning and limiting distracting websites to certain time limits and numbers of launches.

But on days when I feel tired and cranky, I still find myself wasting time, going around the limits I’ve made for myself and falling down the rabbit hole.

I don’t have an answer of how I can balance this in my life. It’s hard. Having too many options is hard.

Here is what I do right now:

  • I only check social media once a day.
  • I have a fifteen minute time limit on YouTube.
  • All websites are blocked until 11:00.
  • 10 or 20 minute limit on websites I commonly get distracted on.
  • I don’t have access to a web browser or a search engine on my phone.

But I feel like I’m falling down a slippery slope, one that I can’t seem to master. Good days, when I’m feeling happy and motivated, I do fine. But the days where I just don’t want to follow my rules. And I don’t.

I’ll keep working on it. I want some sort of conclusion, but I don’t have one.