The world is not the internet

Recently, in the ethics class I teach, we talked about attention. Simone Weil said:

“The authentic and pure values—truth, beauty and goodness—in the activity of a human being are the result of one and the same act, a certain application of the full attention to the object.”

What we give our attention to is really important. And yet, when I look at my life, my attention is often in the wrong place. I like having my phone in my hand. I like having noise around me. I sometimes get distracted with my own thoughts, and I don’t hear what someone is saying to me. My attention is often divided, unfocused.

The things on the internet often capture our attention until we don’t know quite how to attend to anything else.

I am frustrated often with the content I find. Mindless scrolling that no longer seems human anymore. News stories about all the terrible things that are happening. I want to be well-informed, I think, and here is the way to get of all this information, and yet it is full of slop and garbage and those seeking fame. I feel like the world is both crumbling around me, and that I am supposed to laugh at some funny meme at the same time.

I write on this blog and very few people see this. Sometimes I see other subscriber counts it’s easy to feel like what I’m doing doesn’t matter at all. The numbers say that others are reaching thousands and millions of people, and I don’t have that kind of reach. My contributions to the internet are so small and insignificant. No one is paying attention to me.

But the world is not the internet. The world is more than the internet. Those metrics fall apart when we remember what the world is like.

In my ethics class, I usually have an audience of about 25 people twice a week. I talk and share, but I also get to listen. I like the listening part of it, the connection between people. Everyone there is important. My students often surprise me: they are bringing such a depth of experience to the world, each of them with wildly different stories, and yet we can connect over shared values, shared frustrations, shared questions. We try to find answers, but the finding of connection is even better, the feeling of sorting through these problems and ideas together, not on our own.

I’m also writing this dissertation and, in my attempt to actually finish it, I have to close myself off and just write and edit and revise. I think I prefer the real-world conversations that don’t need answers, just ideas. But what I am trying to create is a conversation starter, not an authoritative statement. Not many will read my dissertation. But it still feels like it matters. Not only for the project itself, but for what I’ve learned from doing it and what I can share. Not with a huge audience, but with a few people who might find the ideas helpful, who might become part of that conversation.

I talked to one person at an academic conference in depth about some of my ideas. In the metrics of the internet, one connection and one view and one conversation doesn’t matter. But in the world, those singular conversations seem to matter the very most.

On the internet, social media makes us feel disgustingly distracted. News sites make the world seem like it’s falling apart. Search results are filled with AI slop. We encounter a great number of trolls stirring up contention and advertisers looking for our money.

But in the world, the world outside my screen, I encounter connection that feels beautiful and true and good. The world is a beautiful place. Not all of it. But enough that it makes it feel like there is hope, something to be optimistic about–and that there is so much good right now and always.

I see a rainbow hiking down from the peak of the mountain with my husband. I pick up handfuls of snow and see the small crystals while sledding with my daughter. I laugh with an audience as we sit and watch our community put on a musical. I am embraced in a hug that lets me breathe. I meet a new person who is different from me, and yet we find ways to connect. I carve out a space in the world that is home and refuge.

The internet is not the thing we should attend to, though it can give us glimpses and connection into those more important things. There is a real-life world that deserves our attention, the world that has existed before the screens and will keep on existing when we put the screens away. A world full of people, art, connection, ideas, hope. A world where there will always be beauty. Beauty that is not newsworthy and not viewed by thousands or millions. But beauty and connection and love that is more significant, that makes us realize we are not alone.

My life is full of moments that will be forgotten, unrecorded, and viewed only by one person–and those moments are what make life so full of joy.

Leave a Reply