The world is not the internet

Recently, in the ethics class I teach, we talked about attention. Simone Weil said:

“The authentic and pure values—truth, beauty and goodness—in the activity of a human being are the result of one and the same act, a certain application of the full attention to the object.”

What we give our attention to is really important. And yet, when I look at my life, my attention is often in the wrong place. I like having my phone in my hand. I like having noise around me. I sometimes get distracted with my own thoughts, and I don’t hear what someone is saying to me. My attention is often divided, unfocused.

The things on the internet often capture our attention until we don’t know quite how to attend to anything else.

I am frustrated often with the content I find. Mindless scrolling that no longer seems human anymore. News stories about all the terrible things that are happening. I want to be well-informed, I think, and here is the way to get of all this information, and yet it is full of slop and garbage and those seeking fame. I feel like the world is both crumbling around me, and that I am supposed to laugh at some funny meme at the same time.

I write on this blog and very few people see this. Sometimes I see other subscriber counts it’s easy to feel like what I’m doing doesn’t matter at all. The numbers say that others are reaching thousands and millions of people, and I don’t have that kind of reach. My contributions to the internet are so small and insignificant. No one is paying attention to me.

But the world is not the internet. The world is more than the internet. Those metrics fall apart when we remember what the world is like.

In my ethics class, I usually have an audience of about 25 people twice a week. I talk and share, but I also get to listen. I like the listening part of it, the connection between people. Everyone there is important. My students often surprise me: they are bringing such a depth of experience to the world, each of them with wildly different stories, and yet we can connect over shared values, shared frustrations, shared questions. We try to find answers, but the finding of connection is even better, the feeling of sorting through these problems and ideas together, not on our own.

I’m also writing this dissertation and, in my attempt to actually finish it, I have to close myself off and just write and edit and revise. I think I prefer the real-world conversations that don’t need answers, just ideas. But what I am trying to create is a conversation starter, not an authoritative statement. Not many will read my dissertation. But it still feels like it matters. Not only for the project itself, but for what I’ve learned from doing it and what I can share. Not with a huge audience, but with a few people who might find the ideas helpful, who might become part of that conversation.

I talked to one person at an academic conference in depth about some of my ideas. In the metrics of the internet, one connection and one view and one conversation doesn’t matter. But in the world, those singular conversations seem to matter the very most.

On the internet, social media makes us feel disgustingly distracted. News sites make the world seem like it’s falling apart. Search results are filled with AI slop. We encounter a great number of trolls stirring up contention and advertisers looking for our money.

But in the world, the world outside my screen, I encounter connection that feels beautiful and true and good. The world is a beautiful place. Not all of it. But enough that it makes it feel like there is hope, something to be optimistic about–and that there is so much good right now and always.

I see a rainbow hiking down from the peak of the mountain with my husband. I pick up handfuls of snow and see the small crystals while sledding with my daughter. I laugh with an audience as we sit and watch our community put on a musical. I am embraced in a hug that lets me breathe. I meet a new person who is different from me, and yet we find ways to connect. I carve out a space in the world that is home and refuge.

The internet is not the thing we should attend to, though it can give us glimpses and connection into those more important things. There is a real-life world that deserves our attention, the world that has existed before the screens and will keep on existing when we put the screens away. A world full of people, art, connection, ideas, hope. A world where there will always be beauty. Beauty that is not newsworthy and not viewed by thousands or millions. But beauty and connection and love that is more significant, that makes us realize we are not alone.

My life is full of moments that will be forgotten, unrecorded, and viewed only by one person–and those moments are what make life so full of joy.

living and dreaming with reality

When I was young, we got a newspaper delivered to our house. I remember reading columns and loving the stories found there. I wanted to write a newspaper column when I grew up. But the world changes. Newspaper columns are not what they used to be, so that dream is dead.

I’ve had lots of dreams throughout my life. Years ago, I wanted to teach writing courses in college. I do actually teach college courses as a PhD student, but it’s a whole different world than what I imagined. Things have changed: the rise of generative AI with accompanied cheating, grade inflation, budget cuts, increased and underpaid adjunct faculty, and a toxic job market process make teaching in higher education a lot less appealing.

When you’re young, you try to plan out a pathway only to find out that that pathway as you imagined it never really existed. Most people don’t work in a job that is directly related to their degree in college.

There’s a song that says, “We have all learned to kill our dreams.” And we do have to learn that something that looks really great from the outside may end up not being a good fit for us at all. Our dreams are simply just dreams, imaginary things that are incompatible with reality.

But then reality can actually be a lot better.

We don’t usually dream about the simple moments of life, but those moments are where the happiness comes from. My best moments lately: Playing outside with my family. Hiking in the mountains. When a friend noticed I was down and texted me after church. Reading a good book. Laughing while playing a game. Talking to a stranger about their life.

Success and happiness are not found when we achieve our goals, but in the simple moments along the way. Sometimes when we dream we need to stop focusing so much on what we want to accomplish and focus more on how we want to live, and how we can nurture those moments that bring us joy.

Characters over plot

When you write a novel, you have to get the characters down or the plot doesn’t matter at all. You can have a really awesome plot with great scenes and cool action sequences and whatever, but if you don’t make the reader care about your characters, your reader will hate the book.

But that is just art mimicking life. Because in life, the characters (people) matter a lot more than the plot.

A lot of times we are focused on plot. That’s what a to-do list is, really. The actions that you go through in life. Our goals our often focus on the plot of our life: what we do and where we go.

But who we are with is more important.

I often remember times in my life not by what I accomplished, but by the people that were there. Family and friendship simply matter more than aspirations and achievement.

Ordering from the menu

I saw a post a while ago, first that mentioned that of course there is a God, because he created all these wonderful things for us. And the second post was about how God is more like some sort of chef that should be in the back kitchen, but you put your order in, and nothing comes out. People tell you to keep trying, so you try again and again, and you never get a response.

I understood that feeling. I have often felt that my heartfelt prayers went unanswered. I would plead that I could receive something to get me through a difficult time, and then nothing came.

But then I wondered about that metaphor: God doesn’t have a menu. God does not give what we ask of him, bending his will to what we think we need.

There have been many times in my life when my prayers have been answered in ways I did not expect, and sometimes in ways that were frustrating to me. But they were answered, even if it took a long time for me to see it.

God sometimes gives me what I ask for, but sometimes he gives me something completely different. My life is very different than I expected or wanted, and it has been beautiful and miraculous, even when it has been difficult.

If we are waiting for prayers to be answered in a certain way on a certain timetable, then we will be disappointed. But prayers are still answered. I’ve had evidence of that over and over again in my life, mostly as God helps me become a better person.

Courage is better than confidence

I’m currently teaching an in-person class. I’m new to teaching, and I’m doing the best that I can, but sometimes I don’t have a lot of confidence in myself. And that’s okay.

Because confidence isn’t particularly motivating. I can be very confident that I can do something, but still not want to do it at all. I can feel capable and skilled, but that doesn’t meant I get up and do it.

Courage can be what motivates me to actually do the thing.

Getting a PhD has taken a lot of courage. I had to apply, and I had to get letters of recommendation, and pick out a writing sample that I thought would be good enough. And now I submit to conferences and teach classes. I reach out to committee members, and I meet with my advisor regularly. I get harsh feedback sometimes, and I keep going.

But I don’t feel particularly good at any of this. I know I’m good enough to be here and do this thing, but I still have a lot to learn. I keep on growing.

Courage helps me in those days when I know I’m struggling, but that I go out and I try anyway. I have courage when I raise my hand to ask a question sometimes. When I meet a new person and have to engage in small talk. When I want to go home and crawl in bed and not face the things in front of me, but I instead get up and do my best.

If we wait until we are confident, then we don’t give ourselves the time and the space to learn. My best research is not when I figure it out on my own, but when I bring the beginning of an idea and share it with others. When I’m not confident, and I’m ready to learn and change, and I learn so much in that space.

So don’t seek out confidence. It will come when it’s ready, and it doesn’t ever need to be there at all. Instead, seek courage, to get up and try even when you don’t feel like it.

Home: The Safe Place

My kids behave their absolute worst at home. So do I, when it comes down to it. We all yell and scream and cry. Home becomes a place where all those emotions come out.

It can be discouraging. I would like our home to be calm and clean and happy. But so often it feels like my home is full of garbage: Actual garbage. Emotional garbage. All those worst moments that I wish didn’t exist.

I think the wrong way to deal with this is to try to eliminate all those bad moments. Because those bad moments need to happen. We all need a place where we can behave without expectations for a moment.

And home can be that safe place. Home is the place where we can scream and cry and struggle. We put on a face everywhere else, and then at home we can totally relax and let all of the garage out, that garbage that we keep hidden.

It’s a really good thing that my kids behave badly at home. Because they feel safe there. They feel like they can.

Home becomes sacred because it houses all of us, not just the good bits.

Working Hard

I’ve always wanted to be the sort of person that buckles down, focuses completely, and gets lot of work done in a short amount of time. And while that does happen on occasion, I’m often distracted and off-track.

This semester has been particularly intense. I’ve enjoyed the work (for the most part). But sometimes my life gets a little out of balance, and I don’t always deal with stress well.

For some of my life, I would get really discouraged if the beginning of my day didn’t go quite right. I would feel really guilty, and that guilt would overwhelm me and I no longer had motivation to do anything. One mistake would expand into a whole day of just feeling bad and not doing much.

I don’t do that anymore. I realized that feeling guilty over certain things was not worth it. If I notice that I got distracted, I don’t need to feel guilty. I just need to refocus. If a day is going differently as planned, I don’t need to get discouraged; I just need to embrace whatever the day is.

Sometimes trying to create better habits can do more harm than good when you approach habits in the wrong way. Habits need exceptions. If you try to do something every day that you’ve never done before, you’re going to miss days. And then you might give up. But instead, it’s better to keep trying and release the guilt that you’ll never always be on track. Your habits need to work for you; you don’t need to be a slave to your habits.

I try to recognize the good that I am doing instead of just thinking of everything that isn’t getting done. I want to improve very much, but my main motivation for improvement does not need to be a sense of shame that I’m failing.

Life is unexpected. I need to flexibly adapt to it. And that means that some days, I don’t have a ton of motivation. Some days I end up in my pajamas longer than I expect. Some days the to-do list doesn’t get done. Some days are hard.

I have papers to read; papers to write; friends to check in with; meals to make. I need to take care of myself, take care of my family, and take care of my schoolwork. But sometimes I’m going to get distracted–and sometimes I need those distractions.

And then I brush myself off, and start working again.

Trust

In one of my classes, we’ve talked a lot about trust. We covered three basic account of trust:

  1. Trust is attributing good will to other people.
  2. Trust is about keeping commitments/contracts.
  3. Trust as an unquestioning attitude .

And I came up with my own version:

  • When you trust something or someone, you think it’s not dangerous and won’t harm you.

I was leading a class discussion and I asked two questions: what do you trust that you probably should not trust? And what should you trust that you probably should?

It was easier for us to find answers to the first question. Social media. Smart phones. Bureaucracies that don’t care about you. Grades.

But people didn’t really have an answer to the second. Here was my answer: People who love you, who have your best interest at heart, and who give you really good advice and feedback. And here’s another answer, that I couldn’t say in class: we often can trust God a whole lot more. We can not question his plan for our life, and trust that he will take care of us.

Kind to Yourself

Jesus Christ suffered for me so that I don’t have to suffer. He helps me to become better, patient with my mistakes as he offers healing, hope, and repentance. He treats me with overwhelming lovingkindness.

But how do I treat myself?

Sometimes I am downright mean to myself. It’s like I find myself wallowing in the mud, so I simultaneously yell at myself for being there while pushing my face back into the filth as punishment.

I sabotage my own change, not through weakness, but through cruelty as I tell myself that I don’t deserve better and that I’ll never be good enough.

I criticize constantly, picking at flaws and putting a magnifying glass up to things that don’t matter. There are physical characteristics that no one ever notices or cares about, and I point them out to myself, as if I could never be beautiful. I ruin my own time management in the simultaneous pursuit of too much that doesn’t matter and not enough that does, and then I become overwhelmed with shame that I can never get it right.

I treat myself in a way that I would never treat anyone else. I want to become better, but I am so nasty to myself that I get in the way of my own progress.

I want to be kinder to myself than anyone else in the world. I wan to become patient and loving, allowing myself to change without ruining it with my self-punishment.

I can forgive myself. I can allow myself to do better. I can release the shame. I can patiently go forward, step by step.

And as I love myself more, I become more beautiful as I come a little closer to my Savior.

 

Transform

Pain shifts me away from pride and I face the unknown. Uncertain, I embrace the darkness, except for it’s not dark, because there is a fire and it transforms and refines. Pain is the best part of being human. I change as humility allows the disposal of false beliefs. I become beautiful in the unknowing. Doubt births my faith: I no longer know, but I believe.